Play based curricula versus Drill& Kill

January 14, 2011 at 2:41 pm Leave a comment

I am sure that most of my early childhood education friends will enjoy this article, urging play based curricula.

The authors wonder why the nation does not more readily adopt this view. Let me tell you why, from the Sociological angle. The nation is increasingly skeptical of “soft” policies because the nation’s results, especially in education, have plummeted because of such approaches. Michael Barone’ Hard America, Soft America argues this cogently.

Mr. Barone, of course as any human, reads his predilictions into the data. Nevertheless, his analysis is instructive. Especially to ivy tower liberals like Sociology professors, I think. I do think it is correct to say that much of the nation concludes that many of the softening moves have proven disastrous. We need better results at the end of our educational pipeline.

Unfortunately, this authors are seeing bad results from hardening moves. The student they work with have facts, but not social skills. Students I teach at that same age (although lower level academically) have neither. They tell me that the hardening intent of No Child Left Behind has had unintended softening effect: teachers can’t fail students, so all students work less.

The answer is to get out of the whipsaw soft/hard, and get a better both/and for a better result. Play based curricula is a good answer and a good example.

Early childhood educators that play based curricula is not “doing nothing” but rather a better, more in-depth inquiry for the child into the issue than drill&kill or worksheets.

For instance, think about a child using the Montessori red rods. He will forever know exactly how long a meter is. Forever will she know that 5 decimeters and 5 more will make 10.
Further, this “guided play” will have developed enthusiasm and self-discipline in study that might be developed no other way.

Early Childhood Educators know this. They probably didn’t know they had a key to the overall national debate about education and the direction of this nation economically and culturally.

Keep up the good work.


Entry filed under: Uncategorized. Tags: , , .

Organizational Strategies Active learning – adult students don’t answer questions – why

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Orgstrat serves mostly people in Texas, although Sharon would be happy to serve others. We think we are already compliant with GDPR. We use any info you give us only for the purposes to which you agreed. At any time you can have your info erased from the Orgstrat’s database. We never sell or share the info.

The contact form below is ONLY for a new online course on how to start a preschool If you want to be in *my list* so you are notified of seminars I am doing or any specials I am running, just email me at

Easy Sign up Contact Form

This is a signup for starting a congregationally affiliated preschool and to be notified of related conference or products.

I will not explode your inbox. I will not sell or share your info.

Sharon’s books

The Government is not a Village. Dialogs across boundaries, busts myths, reveals real science. Offers a positive way forward in early education policy. Go to or Swim with the Dolphins, not with the Sharks Sharon's classic book on conflict reduction available at This is instrumental music, great for calming and focusing. I recommend it for your classroom. WHOLETONES

What People are Saying

Would you like Sharon to come back? “Yes! Every day of the year!” Phillip Merritt Owner of ABC Preparatory Academies in Austin Texas

“Sharon has strong abilities in critical thinking. She also has excellent instincts in grasping issues before all the information has been revealed. There have been some occasions where I assumed what she was saying could not possibly be accurate, but in the end she was proved right when the facts were revealed. I trust (or at least pay serious attention) to her opinions.” Walter Lee, former Engineer, Retired Minister PC(USA), QVR Board Member


“Speaker was at ease and able to relate to all participants. All was very good! ” MNKA member

“You kept everything light and moving along. It was great.” MNKA member

“Thanks so much for doing this topic! I’ve been saying this for a long time and no one seems to be hearing me. You have confirmed that I’m not losing my mind. THANK YOU!” MNKA Member

“We sincerely appreciate the time and effort you put into your presentation. Your presentation was a real blessing to the participants, judging from their evaluations. –Terri Sloan, Weekday Ministries Conference

And what I like to hear most, I usually do: “We want to have you back. When can you come? “

Let me know what challenges you are facing.

We all face dragons and wish someone would come along side and help. Let me know what challenge you are facing. If I can't help, I might know someone else who can. . 512/534-5425 - direct line

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 453 other followers

Thanks to StatCounter for more stats on this site.


%d bloggers like this: